Top Five Waterfront Homes in Sag Harbor Under $3.5 Mil

Sag Harbor has transformed itself into an absolutely perfect place for the sailor or water lover who wants to live in the Hamptons. You have absolutely stunning water views, you have one of the cutest towns in America and you also have some of the best real estate. Here’s our top five homes for sale in Sag Harbor under $3.5 million located on the water.

Rare Waterfront Opportunity on Sag Harbor Cove, $3,295,000

New modern pre construction dream home facing Sag Harbor Cove. Unmatched panoramic vistas make this a stunning opportunity and unique waterfront estate. 3,000-square-foot home with 4 bedrooms, 4.5 baths and gunite pool. Additionally, the property boasts a stone bulkhead and deep water dock. Perfect for throwing parties or enjoying time with your family.

Sag Harbor Village By Air, Land and Sea, $3,200,000
Land your seaplane in Sag Harbor Bay and step onto your private sandy beach in Sag Harbor Village. A new staircase will lead you to a zen-like, newly renovated beach house with all the modern amenities. This centrally located home sits high on a bluff in Sag Harbor Village overlooking Sag Harbor Bay. Three bedrooms, two with waterside terraces overlook your beachfront. Top of the line quality kitchen, living room with wood-burning fireplace. Water views from every room and floor-to-ceiling glass windows and sliders throughout complete this truly chic beach house.

Waterfront in Sag Harbor, $3,200,000
Located on Upper Sag Harbor Cove close to Sag Harbor Village, this beautifully renovated 3-bedroom 3.5-bath home has stunning water views from every room. The house is flooded with natural light from multiple French doors and windows, which create a spacious and airy feel. The first floor master bedroom opens onto a private patio and the water. The second floor has 2 ensuite bedrooms with dramatic water views. A dock and bulkheading complete the picture.

Sag Harbor Cove with Dock, $2,990,000
Adorable 2-bedroom, 2-bath cottage with 110 feet of waterfront and a 40-foot dock on Sag Harbor Cove . Freshly painted and decorated, this charming village bungalow has a waterside master suite, guest room with separate bath, spotless kitchen and waterside dining room. It also has a separate den with gas-burning wood stove—a great place to hang out and watch old movies or read that book you’ve been meaning to finish. Seller would build out 5,000-square-foot two-story house with pool for right buyer.

Bountiful Bayfront! $2,950,000
This 2.29-acre property nestled on the southern bank of Noyac Bay boasts 472 feet of serene bay-front beach. Presently, a quaint 2-bedroom, 1-bath cottage, with a fully renovated interior, rests there—a perfect starting point to build the home of your dreams. Wetlands have been flagged and there is room for a pool.

BACK TO Real Estate