Vote: Create ‘The Montauk’ Cocktail

This week, Dan’s Papers asked our Facebook fans for their suggestions of ingredients to put in a cocktail named “The Montauk.”

We received many answers, ranging from the sincere to the absurd and humorous.

We’ll start with a look at the absurd:

George
A fedora filled with PBR.

Nevets
Essence of hipster

Mick
A bunch of drunk people stumbling in the street between the Memory Motel and the Point, with a garnish of oceanfront motel-soon-to-be private surf club, with the drink price being about 22.5 million. Each drink sold nets the bartender (who moonlights as a real estate agent) a VERY high commission fee.

Gio
Blah blah blah topped with an oyster.

Cynthia
Striped bass.

Ed
A monster

Pam
Keith Richards

Linda
Sand.

Heather 
Clams

Christopher
…SERVED AND RECEIVED WITH A BAD ATTITUDE.

Melissa
Distilled fish juice and if you can handle it… You can stay!

 

And here are the sincere answers. (Some suggestions were for just one ingredient, while others were full-fledged cocktails.)

Mary
Vodka, mint, pineapple, cranberry

Lou
Dark rum for the sun, Blue Curaçao for the ocean, and beer for the lifestyle

Susanna
Long Island Ice-Tea and some Champagne

Jean
Champagne with a splash of Blood Orange juice or liquor

John
Capt Morgan

Andrea
Baileys’ Irish cream with Curaçao

Colin
Vodka Orange raspberry and bitters (“The bitter End” on the rocks!)

Eileen
Blue Curaçao and cream de cocoa (Montauk Mermaid…served on the rocks … of course.)

Kj
PBR with a depth charge of Jäger

Kristen
Firefly ice tea vodka

Southampton Soap Company 1 oz. each vodka, gin, rum topped with Sweet ‘tauk lemonade, garnished with lemon. Sweet ‘tauk

Dan
vodka / cranberry / pineapple / oj

Troi
Rum

We’ve rounded up our favorites and now it is time to vote. The winning cocktail will earn its creator a Dan’s Papers T-shirt, and we will try to actually create the winning drink. (Only vote once. Attempts to manipulate the vote will invalidate the results. And then no one gets  a T-Shirt!)

We're creating a cocktail named "The Montauk." What recipe gets your vote?

  • 1 oz. each vodka, gin and rum topped with Sweet 'tauk lemonade, garnished with lemon. (75% )
  • Vodka, pineapple juice and cranberry juice with mint (9% )
  • Long Island Iced Tea with a splash of Champagne (6% )
  • Champagne with a splash of blood orange liqueur (5% )
  • Raspberry vodka with orange bitters (2% )
  • Dark rum, Blue Curaçao and beer (1% )
  • Blue Curaçao and cream de cocoa (1% )
  • Baileys' Irish Cream with Curaçao (1% )
Loading ... Loading ...

 

BACK TO Hampton Eats

 
logo
You must be logged in to vote.
logo